Gumby's Pizza Reviews

I was half-expecting something small to be off, because that happens sometimes, like a dip missing or the wings tossed in the wrong sauce. But nope — pizza was right, wings were right, all the little extras were there. I opened the bag and was like, okay, perfect. Simple thing, but it makes a difference. Easy 5 stars from me.

Ordering from Gumby’s Pizza online was actually easy, which was a nice surprise because apparently that’s not always a given these days. The site loaded without acting up, and I was able to pick what I wanted without having to fight my way through a million unnecessary steps.
Checkout was simple too, and my order details were clear before I paid, which I appreciated. It’s always refreshing when a website just tells you what you’re ordering and what it costs instead of turning dinner into a small research project.
The pizza came out good, and the order was right, so no complaints there. if the online ordering keeps being this straightforward, I’d definitely use it again.

I took one bite and immediately thought, yep, this crust is a winner. The edges were perfectly crispy, but the middle was still soft and chewy. loved it...

My first impression was really positive, the staff was super friendly right away, and the pizza came out quicker than I expected. Simple, easy, and a nice experience overall.

I had a little mix-up with my order and called the store, fully expecting it to be a whole dramatic ordeal, but they picked up super fast and were so unbelievably nice about it. Like, zero attitude, zero weirdness, just genuinely helpful people who made me feel like I wasn’t being a bother at all.
They got everything fixed really quickly and even checked back to make sure I ended up with the right thing, which made my day way more than it probably should have. It was such a simple thing, but the way they handled it was top-tier. 5 stars from me, no question.

I was kind of feeling pressured to pick something quick for dinner, so I went with this pizza and it turned out great. It had a lot of flavor, the crust had a nice chewy texture, and the cheese tasted really fresh. The sauce also wasn’t too sweet, which I liked. I’d definitely order it again

The pizza was fine, nothing amazing, but I got annoyed with how messy the place was. The tables were sticky, there was trash on the floor, and it just didn’t feel like anyone was in a hurry to clean up. The staff was nice enough, but i don’t really want to sit and eat somewhere that feels that neglected. I’d probably just get it to go next time.

The food was okay once it finally showed up, but wow, the delivery time was rough! It said about 45 minutes, and it ended up being closer to an hour and a half.

I called to see what was going on, and they basically just told me it was on the way?? The pizza itself wasn’t terrible, but waiting that long definitely took the fun out of it.

I ran into a problem at first, but they got it fixed quickly. Really appreciated how smoothly they handled it, and I’d be happy to use them again.

The pizza was decent and I didn’t have a bad experience, but I kind of regret not checking the prices more closely before ordering. It was okay overall, just felt a little high for what I got.

The menu has pretty much everything you could think of. It was almost a little overwhelming at first, actually, that’s not really a bad thing, because it means there’s something for everyone.

I don’t want to be too harsh because the crust was actually fine, but the toppings were a letdown. The mushrooms tasted watery, the pepperoni was sparse, and nothing really tasted that fresh. The cheese was okay, but overall it felt like they cut corners. For the price, I expected better, so I’ll probably play it safe and order from somewhere else next time.

I mean, everything showed up hot and tasted really fresh, so yeah, no complaints from me.

I ordered on gumbyspizza.com for pickup because I was kind of rushing around and didn’t want to deal with a wait. It was really smooth. The food was ready when I got there, the pizza was still hot, and the staff was friendly enough even though I was trying to get in and out fast. Super easy pickup, no problems, and I’d definitely do it again...

The pizza tasted good, no complaints there, but I was a little disappointed by the portion size. For what I paid, I expected more food. Just a heads up if you’re ordering hungry or expecting bigger servings

My pizza got here still nice and hot, which is really all I was hoping for. The cheese was melty, the crust tasted fresh, and it didn’t feel like it had been sitting around on a counter somewhere like some orders do. Happy with it overall, and I’d definitely order again.